Contrarian investing resembles navigating a swift river by swimming against the prevailing current. While most investors opt for the safety of flowing with the crowd (trend trading), contrarian investors deliberately forge their path upstream, carving an unconventional route in the intricate world of finance (contrarian trading).
Rather than unquestioningly adhering to prevailing market trends, contrarian traders sell when others enthusiastically embrace buying, and buy when the majority succumb to panic-driven selling.
In this article, we will delve into contrarian trading, shedding light on the intricacies of this trading style and uncovering ways to navigate its challenges adeptly if you think it might be a good fit for you.
Understanding contrarian trading, its advantages and its risks
Contrarian investing is a strategy in which investors or traders seek to profit by going against the prevailing sentiment of the majority.
For instance, when most people are buying because they believe the economic future looks bright and this optimism is driving asset prices up (experiencing overly bullish sentiment), contrarian investors are instead looking to sell.
Conversely, when most people are selling because they're concerned about the economic
outlook and the performance of financial markets (experiencing overly bearish sentiment), contrarian investors see an opportunity to buy.
Herd mentality plays a pivotal role in the realm of contrarian trading, constituting the very phenomenon that contrarian traders strategically leverage to their advantage.
So, what precisely is this herd mentality? The herd mentality is the tendency for people to act and behave like the majority.
In the trading world, this often translates into a scenario where, when most investors buy a particular asset because it's doing well, others feel compelled to do the same, fearing they might miss out on potential gains (FOMO - Fear Of Missing Out).
Now, let's delve into how contrarian trading stands in stark contrast to this prevailing herd mindset.
Contrarian trading, as implied by its name and as we’ve explained, runs counter to this crowd-driven impulse.
Instead of mindlessly trailing with the masses, contrarian traders chart a course in the opposite direction. They deliberately seek opportunities that defy the prevailing market sentiment and adopt a different stance from the majority.
They often choose to sell when most are buying, minimizing their involvement with potentially overpriced assets. Conversely, during episodes of widespread panic-induced selling, contrarians see the opportunity to acquire undervalued assets, which can help curtail potential losses.
In this way, contrarian trading serves as a strategic counterbalance to conventional market trends, offering a safeguard against market fluctuations.
As the essence of contrarian trading lies in its ability to question and challenge the consensus, and because contrarian traders do not succumb to the emotional sway of the crowd, they introduce an element of equilibrium to the market dynamics.
This equilibrium is particularly reminiscent of value investing.
Value investors share the belief that markets are not always rational and efficient in pricing assets. Instead of following the crowd, value investors seek to identify assets that are undervalued relative to their intrinsic worth.
They recognize that in the midst of market fervor or fear, opportunities can emerge that defy conventional wisdom, but help them capitalize on mispriced securities.
Another advantage of contrarian trading is that traders following this trading style often develop strong discipline and mental resilience. They learn to make decisions based on analysis and reason, rather than succumbing to the emotional highs and lows that can lead to impulsive actions.
By going against the crowd, contrarian traders are also less likely to engage in crowded trades, where everyone is on one side of the market. This can reduce competition and increase the potential for profit when the market reverses.
This technique also helps them thrive during market crises when panic selling drives down prices. They can swoop in to buy quality assets at deep discounts, positioning themselves for substantial gains when markets stabilize and go back up.
Finally, contrarian trading is adaptable and can be applied to various asset classes, which allows traders to actively manage their portfolios across different markets - Forex, stocks, indices, commodities, ETF, etc.
Contrarian trading, while potentially rewarding when successful by enabling traders to buy low and sell high or vice versa, is accompanied by inherent risks.
Going against the prevailing market sentiment exposes contrarian traders to the possibility of short-term losses, or finding themselves in positions ahead of the market's adjustment to their contrarian perspective.
Contrarian trading demands precise timing.
Given that contrarian traders frequently act in opposition to the prevailing market sentiment, they may not receive immediate validation of the correctness of their contrarian stance. This lack of confirmation can be emotionally challenging, leading to feelings of isolation and self-doubt, among others.
Furthermore, contrarian traders face the risk of missing out on substantial gains during prolonged market uptrends.
Consistently betting against a robust trend can result in underperformance relative to strategies that follow prevailing trends - not to mention that every contrarian move in the market culminates in a market reversal.
Sometimes, what initially appears to be a contrarian opportunity may ultimately prove to be a false signal, resulting in financial losses.
The importance of measuring the market sentiment in contrarian trading and how to do it
Measuring market sentiment is paramount in contrarian trading as it provides valuable insights into prevailing crowd psychology, enabling contrarian traders to discern potential opportunities and risks.
One of its key functions is to serve as a signal indicator for potential contrarian opportunities.
Contrarian traders can effectively identify periods when the majority of investors exhibit either excessive optimism (a bearish signal for contrarians) or unwarranted pessimism (a bullish signal for contrarians).
Moreover, measuring sentiment plays a pivotal role in helping contrarian traders gauge the level of risk inherent in the market and anticipate future market dynamics.
When a sense of euphoria prevails, contrarian traders can proactively prepare for potential market corrections. Conversely, during episodes of extreme fear, they can be forewarned of potential reversals, allowing them to adapt their strategies accordingly.
But now, the question that arises is: How does one go about measuring market sentiment effectively?
Well, to be able to trade by taking into account market sentiment, you will mostly have to use metrics and tools combining technical and fundamental analysis.
You can have a look at the VIX index, the trading volume, the Commitment of Traders (COT), the put/call ratio, the high/low ratio, short interest ratio, and the fear and greed index.
It is also possible to sport divergences with technical indicators, such as the Moving Average Convergence Divergence (MACD), the Momentum, the Rate of Change (ROC), the Relative Strength Index (RSI), and Average Directional Index (ADX).
You can also keep an eye on news sources, financial media, and social media platforms to gauge the current sentiment. Additionally, employing social listening tools can help you monitor online discussions and sentiment.
Some famous contrarian investors and what they’re saying about it
You're likely familiar with the renowned contrarian investor Warren Buffett, particularly his well-known adage: "Be fearful when others are greedy, and greedy when others are fearful", which encapsulates his contrarian investment philosophy.
David Dreman, Jim Rogers, Seth Klarman, John Templeton, Carl Icahn, Michael Burry, Marc Faber, Howard Marks…
…all of them are famous contrarian investors that have demonstrated that going against the crowd and maintaining a disciplined, long-term approach to investing can lead to financial success.
In the ever-churning waters of financial markets, contrarian trading stands as the compass that charts a path less traveled, reminding us that sometimes, the boldest profits emerge when you dare to swim against the tide.
The information provided does not constitute investment research. The material has not been prepared in accordance with the legal requirements designed to promote the independence of investment research and as such is to be considered to be a marketing communication.
All information has been prepared by ActivTrades (“AT”). The information does not contain a record of AT’s prices, or an offer of or solicitation for a transaction in any financial instrument. No representation or warranty is given as to the accuracy or completeness of this information.
Any material provided does not have regard to the specific investment objective and financial situation of any person who may receive it. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future performance. AT provides an execution-only service. Consequently, any person acting on the information provided does so at their own risk.